0

1923: Spencer Dutton’s Family Tree Gets Official Update — And It’s Not What Fans Wanted

The historic legacy of the Dutton family got a shock update after the season 2 finale of 1923 aired on Paramount+ this month. For years, fans believed that Spencer Dutton (Brandon Sklenar) and Alexandra (Julia Schlaepfer) had fathered John Dutton II — setting up Spencer as the grandfather of modern-day patriarch John Dutton III (Kevin Costner) in Yellowstone. But according to Sklenar, the show never confirmed that Spencer’s baby is indeed John II, throwing the lineage into doubt — and leaving fans frustrated. New York Post+15The Direct+15Decider+15

What We Knew — and What Changed

Background: In 1923, viewers were introduced to Spencer’s wartime return and Alexandra’s unexpected pregnancy. The finale even showed them naming their premature baby John — a moment that many interpreted as definitive confirmation of the iconic Dutton lineage.

However, in post-finale interviews, Sklenar threw a massive curveball:

“We still can’t confirm 100% that John Dutton is the John Dutton… there’s a lot of Johns out there.” Whiskey Riff+2The Direct+2FilmoFilia+2

Now, the certainty surrounding Spencer’s line carrying through to Yellowstone has evaporated — and fans are unsettled.

Why This Revelation Matters

1. Family Legacy Disrupted
Spencer was built up as the heir who’d carry Dutton blood into the next era — a dramatic payoff for 1883, 1923, and Yellowstone’s multigenerational saga. This ambiguity undermines that narrative bridge.

2. Canonical Conflict
The revelation contradicts well-established details: Elsa Dutton’s voiceover in Yellowstone defined John III as the fifth generation, making Spencer’s son John II the logical link. Sklenar and Sheridan now muddy the timeline and raise continuity questions. Reddit+1Reddit+1

3. Fan Frustration
Social media and fan forums have lit up with confusion and disappointment. Many argue that the ‘jaw-dropping moment’ of naming Spencer’s baby John now feels hollow — or worse, misleading.

What the Fans Are Saying

In Reddit’s r/1923Series, opinions vary but tension is clear:

• “There is no official family tree… Elsa’s VO said only one child would shepherd the family through the 20th century—Spencer.”

• “The generations don’t line up for Spencer to be grandfather… Jack seems far more likely.” Reddit

• And yet, others point out the show’s history of secrecy and sudden twists: “TS isn’t great on these details but I trust him.” Reddit

What’s at Stake for Future Stories

📺 Spinoff Clarity Needed
Upcoming projects, such as 1944, will have to address the lineage question — and quickly — if they want to fill plot gaps for Season 2’s sometimes ambiguous ending.

🧬 Identity & Character Arcs
If Spencer’s baby isn’t John II, it raises questions: is another sibling involved? Was a baby switch afoot? Or will the Dutton legacy follow a different branch entirely?

🌾 Thematic Ramifications
Yellowstone’s themes of land, bloodline, and destiny hinge on generational continuity. Undermining that threatens the emotional resonance of the entire saga — and fans notice.

Where Things Might Go From Here

1. Confirmation in 1944
Expect the next prequel to resolve this — or introduce a new twist that redeploys genetically Dutton heirs.

2. A Hidden Sibling?
Could Elizabeth and Jack’s pregnancy from earlier in 1923 yield a different paternal path for John II?

3. A Redefined Legacy
Maybe Sheridan wants to shift focus: not on direct descendants, but on chosen family and the resilience of the Dutton name.

📝 Final Thoughts

What seemed like a triumphant tying together of 1923 and Yellowstone is now a jumbled family tree. Spencer’s character, built up as a linchpin, is overshadowed by uncertainty. For some fans, the surprise dials up intrigue — but for others, the confusion feels like a betrayal.

One thing is for sure: without a concrete canon fix, the core meaning of the family saga — that 7 generations guard this land — risks becoming a myth without roots. Sheridan might have intended suspense, but now the question is: will 1923 and future prequels deliver the answers fans want?

Want deep dives into fans’ theories, breakdowns of Dutton generational signage, or implications for upcoming spinoffs?