Emmerdale Fans ‘WORK OUT’ Who M*rdered Nate Robinson—And It’s Not Who You’d Expect!

Emmerdale fans are convinced they’ve uncovered the shocking truth behind Nate Robinson’s mysterious death—and the real killer might be an unexpected soap legend.

Last month, Amy Barton made the chilling discovery of Nate’s lifeless body in an icy lake, following the devastating limo crash that claimed the lives of three villagers. In her final moments at the hospital, suffering from hypothermia, Amy desperately tried to get a message across to Matty. Struggling for breath, she whispered, “Matty… Nate is in the water,” but Matty, unaware of the urgency, simply reassured her, “You’re safe now.” With her strength fading, Amy repeated, “Nate is in the water,” before gasping a final “I love you.” Tragically, she passed away before confirming if Matty truly understood what she meant.

Since Nate left for Shetland in 2024, Tracy Robinson has heard nothing from him. Despite numerous attempts to reach him after the limo disaster, his silence has fueled speculation about what really happened. Now, fans believe they’ve figured it out. While initial theories pointed fingers at Caleb Milligan, John Sutton, or Mackenzie Boyd, a shocking new possibility has emerged—Moira Dingle.

Earlier this year, Emmerdale aired flash-forwards that showed Mackenzie in a frantic state, appearing to flee from something—or someone. Now, fans believe he might have been running from the lake after disposing of Nate’s body, not because he killed him, but to protect his sister, Moira.

Moira was diagnosed with a brain tumor last year, which caused mood swings, seizures, and memory loss. Some fans theorize she may have accidentally killed Nate during an episode and has no recollection of it. Did Mack cover for his sister to spare her the truth? If the latest fan theories are correct, Emmerdale could be gearing up for one of its most explosive revelations yet!