One of the most talked-about mysteries heading into Virgin River Season 6 is the sudden disappearance of Charmaine Roberts, the character who has been both loved and hated since the show’s beginning. Played by Lauren Hammersley, Charmaine has spent years at the heart of the drama, from her complicated relationship with Jack Sheridan to her shocking pregnancy reveal and the later bombshell that Jack was not the father of her twins. Now, with whispers that her presence in Season 6 may be significantly reduced—or that she could vanish altogether—fans are speculating about how and why this might happen. There are three major theories that have gained traction within the fandom, each offering a different perspective on Charmaine’s fate and what her absence could mean for the story.
Theory One: Charmaine Leaves Virgin River to Start Fresh Somewhere New
The first and perhaps most straightforward theory is that Charmaine decides to leave Virgin River altogether in search of a new beginning. After years of heartache, failed romances, and tangled loyalties, it would not be surprising if she finally chose to step away from the town that has defined her struggles. The revelation that Jack is not the father of her twins shook her to her core, leaving her to face the reality that she may have used denial to avoid the truth. In leaving Virgin River, Charmaine could be choosing independence over constant disappointment.
This storyline would allow the writers to give her a redemptive exit. Instead of portraying her as the perpetual antagonist, they could show her strength in walking away and carving out her own identity. For many fans, this would be a satisfying conclusion: Charmaine would no longer be trapped in the endless cycle of competing for Jack’s affection or trying to prove her worth to the community. Instead, she could be remembered as a character who, despite her flaws, ultimately took control of her own destiny.
If this theory proves true, her departure would not only resolve her arc but also open space in the narrative for new characters and fresh storylines. It could also create the potential for her to return in later seasons, stronger and more grounded, should the writers wish to reintroduce her down the road.
Theory Two: A Custody Battle and Legal Drama Take Center Stage
The second theory is more dramatic: Charmaine may not disappear willingly at all. Instead, her absence could be tied to a custody battle over her twins. Now that Jack has been confirmed not to be the father, the true paternity of her children remains an open question. If the real father steps forward and demands a role in their lives, Charmaine could find herself caught up in a legal struggle.
