🤰 The Twist So Far

• In Season 5, it was confirmed that Charmaine’s twins aren’t Jack’s children—the true father is Calvin, the drug lord presumed dead who suddenly reappears to claim parenthood TechRadar+15EW.com+15GoodtoKnow+15.

• 

🤔 What Fans Think: Theories & Speculation

• Mike the cop?
  Numerous fans theorized that Mike Valenzuela, Jack’s army buddy turned detective, could be the father based on his uneasy reaction when Charmaine revealed her pregnancy Woman & HomeScreen Rant+1Looper+1. One Redditor wrote:

  “I think Charmaine’s babies are Mike’s… his reaction was really intense.” Marie Claire+15Looper+15Screen Rant+15

• Brady connection?
  Another idea pointed to Brady as the father. Actor Ben Hollingsworth even joked this might be the case—but there was no concrete proof TIME+5What to Watch+5Decider+5.

• Off-screen lover?
  Some believe Charmaine had a fling with someone unknown to viewers, suggesting the father might be a completely new character Oprah Daily.

🤱 Why “Charmaine Might Not Be the Only One Having Jack’s Babies”

With Calvin confirmed as the biological father, the title becomes more layered: Jack bonded emotionally with the twins, only to have his parental identity stripped away. So while Calvin is the dad, Jack was raising them—making him a second “father” in a sense, especially in terms of emotional connection. That’s why fans say Charmaine and Jack both “had” Jack’s babies—she carried them, he loved them, but neither was biologically theirs Reddit+5Reddit+5Reddit+5.

✅ What This Means for Upcoming Seasons

• Calvin’s full appearance is expected to deepen the emotional stakes—he’s not just a looming figure anymore.

• Jack’s journey of emotional healing may center on recognizing the loss of a relationship that felt real.

• Calvin vs. Jack might clash over custody, purpose, and legitimacy.

• Mel and Jack’s adoption arc could evolve differently now: if Calvin takes his kids or disappears, that may impact the surrogacy storyline teased at the end of Season 6 Reddit+3TechRadar+3Reddit+3.

📝 Summary

• Charmaine’s twins are biologically Calvin’s, not Jack’s Woman & Home+3EW.com+3GoodtoKnow+3.

• Fans originally speculated other fathers—Mike, Brady, even mystery men—before Calvin’s reveal .

• But emotionally and narratively, Jack was a father, which complicates the idea that he “didn’t have Jack’s babies.”

• Season 7 will likely follow Calvin’s entrance and the ripple effects on all relationships in Virgin River.